Eskom: Donï¿½t Dam the Zambezi!
June 21, 2010
To: Brian Dames
Chief Executive Officer, Eskom
By e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
This year is the 10th anniversary of the World Commission on Damsï¿½
groundbreaking work to create higher standards for dam projects ï¿½
standards intended to avoid undue harm to our rivers and those who
depend on them. South Africa was the home for the Commission (ï¿½WCDï¿½),
and has been at the forefront in adopting the WCDï¿½s recommendations.
Yet Eskomï¿½s potential involvement in the controversial Mphanda Nkuwa
Dam in Mozambique threatens to undo that legacy. The proposed dam
will create lasting social and environmental problems, and compound
the damage to the Zambezi River caused by Cahora Bassa Dam ï¿½ another
destructive hydro project whose electricity primarily benefits Eskom,
but whose costs are borne by Mozambique.
More than that, Mphanda Nkuwa is a risky investment in a time of
climate change. Southern Africaï¿½s rivers will become less predictable
in a warming climate. The dam could prove to be a white elephant if
extended droughts make it an unreliable source of electricity.
The Lower Zambezi is vital to the national economy in Mozambique.
Under natural flow conditions, its waters support extensive flood-
recession agricultural systems, productive freshwater fisheries,
coastal prawn fisheries, and healthy habitat for wildlife. Over the
past 50 years of river regulation, these systems have all declined
precipitously. The Zambezi is now one of the most heavily dammed
rivers in Africa.
Mphanda Nkuwa will make it more difficult to adopt better management
at existing dams to resolve the riverï¿½s problems.
Mphanda Nkuwa Damï¿½s electricity will fuel industries in South Africa,
but in Mozambique it will cause daily mini-floods that will worsen the
situation of an already impoverished population. Approximately 100,000
people risk losing their livelihoods, but only a fraction of them
will be compensated. This type of project, which sacrifices the lives
of the poor and does lasting damage to the environment on which we all
depend, should have no place in South Africaï¿½s energy portfolio.
Eskom over time has had various ï¿½confidentialï¿½ agreements with the
Mozambican government on the dam. Now it may soon sign a power
purchase agreement on the project, which is key to the project going
forward. We urge Eskom to rethink its involvement in this
Our organizations lobby for clean energy for South Africa and
Mozambique. Our research has shown that South Africa has the potential
to quickly reduce its own electricity consumption by an amount
equivalent to 3 to 5 times Mozambiqueï¿½s entire consumption. Indeed,
South Africa could save 3,000 MW in the next four years (and much more
in the long run) by making existing system more efficient.
A large proportion of South Africa's and Mozambique's electricity
benefits a single company, BHP Billiton, which receives power at US
$0.015 (i.e. 1.5 cents) per kiloWatt hour, by far the cheapest price
in the world. This is due to apartheid-era deals which cost Eskom $1.3
billion in losses in 2009. They are being renegotiated, but secretly,
and a similar price is anticipated to result.
South Africa also has huge potential for clean, renewable energy. It
is time to move more quickly to develop these resources, and to stop
relying on destructive mega-coal and mega-hydro plants.
Africaï¿½s biggest utility should be setting standards for an African
development renaissance that is sustainable, and socially and
environmentally just. Mphanda Nkuwa does not meet those standards.
JA! Justica Ambiental, Friends of the Earth Mozambique
groundWork, Friends of the Earth, South Africa
Biowatch South Africa
South Africa Water Caucus
Centre for Civil Society Environmental Justice Project (University of
KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa)
Port Elizabeth Renewable Energy Centre
South Durban Community Environmental Alliance
African Rivers Network (Pan African)
Citizens for Justice-(CFJ), Friends of the Earth Malawi
Friends of the Earth Ghana
National Association of Professional Environmentalist (Uganda)
Kulali Development Foundation (Zambia)
Survivors of Lesotho Dams (Lesotho)
Transformation Resource Centre (Lesotho)
Society for Water and Public Health Protection (Nigeria)
Environmental Rights Action (Nigeria)
International Rivers (USA)
You received this message as a subscriber on the list: email@example.com
To be removed from the list, please visit: