Dam firm violated law
By Shane Worrell
5 June 2013, Phnom Penh Post
A villager looks to the Sesan river in Stung Treng province's Sesan
district in April. Photograph: Vireak Mai/Phnom Penh Post The parent
company behind a firm constructing the Lower Sesan 2 dam in Stung Treng
has repeatedly violated Chinese law by building ï¿½massiveï¿½ power projects
without prior approval, China's national auditor has found.
State-owned China Huaneng Group, of which Lower Sesan 2 partner
Hydrolancang International Energy is a subsidiary, undertook projects
including a 1,900 megawatt dam on the Mekong River without permission, a
report released last month by China's National Audit office says.
"As of the end of 2011, Huaneng had begun construction of 16 major
projects ï¿½ including the Huangdeng hydropower station ï¿½ without prior
approval," the report states, adding that the projects were worth
billions of US dollars.
In total, the auditor adds, the state-owned firm had begun 75 projects
by the end of 2011, "but 81,226.27 acres [3,2871 hectares] of land that
the projects were being built on had not yet been approved for
The auditor also found that the company had over-reported assets,
liabilities and profits, because its management procedures "lacked
stringency and standardisation".
An employee at Huaneng's office in China declined to give his name
yesterday and said the company could not provide comment.
Hydrolancang, which is owned by Huaneng, announced last November it
would build the 400-megawatt, $781 million Lower Sesan 2 dam in
partnership with Cambodia's Royal Group at the confluence of the Sesan
and Srepok rivers. Parliament has since approved the project, but
riverside communities say they have not been given information about
relocation or compensation, despite swathes of trees already being
cleared to make way for the resulting reservoir. Environmental groups
have said the Lower Sesan 2 poses serious risks to the Mekong River's
fish stocks and bioversity.
Ame Trandem, Southeast Asia program director for International Rivers,
said the "major violations" revealed by the audit showed there was no
guarantee the Lower Sesan 2 would be built in accordance with Cambodian law.
"If they can't follow laws in China, why would they follow any laws
within Cambodia?" she said. "[Hydrolancang] is their company . . . there
are serious concerns with the way they will act."
Hydrolancang was likely to play a leading role in resettling thousands
of people affected by the Lower Sesan 2, which was "concerning", because
it had built the first dam on China's part of the Mekong River with
ï¿½disastrousï¿½ consequences for villagers, Trandem added.
"A lot of communities . . . waited over 20 years for adequate
compensation." Trandem's comments came on the sidelines of the Mekong
and 3S Hydropower Dams forum, which concluded in Phnom Penh yesterday
with representatives of communities and NGOs from Cambodia, Thailand and
Vietnam calling for the controversial dam to be scrapped.
"The Lower Sesan 2 dam should be cancelled due to the immense harm the
project poses to the Mekong River Basin's fisheries, sedimentation and
other natural resources and the livelihoods and food security of the
people of Cambodia, as well as neighbouring countries," a joint
Participants also called for governments to abandon projects such as the
Xayaburi dam, which is under construction in northern Laos, and for
financiers and investors to comply with international standards and
respect human rights and the law.
During the forum, many villagers set to be affected by the Lower Sesan 2
voiced their concerns about the lack of information given to them.
"The Lower Sesan will be built and we will be relocated," one villager
said. "I ask for everyone to help us ï¿½ we can't help ourselves."
Kith Meng, chairman of Royal Group, could not be reached for comment,
while Ministry of Industry, Mining and Energy secretary of state Ith
Praing said he was in a meeting and could not respond to questions.
Additional reporting by Danson Cheong and May Titthara
This is International Rivers' mailing list on China's global footprint, and particularly Chinese investment in
international dam projects.
You received this message as a subscriber on the list: email@example.com
To be removed from the list, please visit: