Chinese Ambassador Casts Doubt On Myitsone Resumption
By Myanmar Times, July 19th, 2013
The Chinese ambassador to Myanmar said he is "not confident" that the
suspended Myitsone Dam project will be restarted, despite continued
lobbying by China Power Investment Corporation.
In an exclusive interview with The Myanmar Times, ambassador Yang Houlan
said CPI's efforts to address concerns surrounding the project, which
was suspended in September 2011 for at least five years, have had little
"I'm not confident the project can be started," Mr Yang said on July 17.
"For the Chinese company [China Power Investment Corporation], they hope
that they can make some progress through the communications and the
negotiations, but as for now there has been no progress in this regard,"
The head of the embassy's political section, Gao Mingbo, said that he
"didn't have a clear picture at this stage" whether work would resume on
the hydropower dam in 2015, which is the earliest the suspension could
President U Thein Sein halted the project following fierce opposition
from environmentalists, ethnic minority groups and political activists,
including Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.
With 90 percent of the electricity generated to be exported to China,
many saw the project as bringing few benefits to Myanmar.
Myitsone is not the only China-backed project to face such criticisms.
The Letpadaung copper mine, a joint venture between military-owned Union
of Myanmar Economic Holdings Limited and Wanbao, and oil and natural gas
pipelines linking Rakhine State and Yunnan Province have also been
marred by similar accusations.
Mr Yang admitted that the approach Chinese companies had taken in the
past, which he described as "do more, speak less", was no longer
"We are not so experienced on how to communicate with local people, how
to make more feasibility studies on the environment and issues connected
with local p[peoples' welfare," said Mr Yang, adding that Chinese firms
could learn from how Western companies approach foreign investment.
Led by Mr Yang, a seasoned diplomat who arrived in Yangon in March after
stints as ambassador in Afghanistan, the Korean peninsula and Nepal, the
Chinese Embassy has stepped up its efforts to improve China's image in
Myanmar. As The Myanmar Times has previously reported, the embassy has
sought to engage Myanmar internet users through social media,
particularly Facebook. It also plans to re-launch its Myanmar-language
magazine, China Today, later this month.
As part of these efforts, the Chinese-Myanmar Enterprises Association
(CMEA), which comprises about 100 Chinese companies that work in
Myanmar, issued a new set of corporate social responsibility (CSR)
initiatives on July 5 in conjunction with the embassy. The two-page
document calls for greater environmental protection, transparency and
interaction with local communities in future projects.
"We are asking [Chinese companies] to adapt to the new situation," Mr
The guidelines show that Chinese companies understand the need to change
their practices but the important test will be whether they are adhered
to. Mr Yang said the embassy would work to ensure compliance but there
is a risk that, however well-intentioned, the guidelines will end up
looking like a public relations stunt.
While maintaining a smile throughout the interview, Mr Yang was clearly
frustrated over the expectations that Chinese companies single-handedly
carry out CSR projects with little or no help from Nay Pyi Taw.
"There are some things that should be the duty of the government but now
the investors have to take charge," Mr Yang said. He cited schools built
by China National Petroleum Corporation along the route of the
China-Myanmar pipelines as an example. Mr Yang said that after the
schools were built the company received complaints from residents that
it had not supplied teachers to staff them.
"Teachers are the government's responsibility. The Chinese company
cannot provide teachers for the schools," Mr Yang said.
He said he felt Chinese companies were also unfairly singled out when
working on projects with companies from other countries, while the
benefits Myanmar could reap from these projects are also rarely reported
in the media.
This is International Rivers' mailing list on China's global footprint, and particularly Chinese investment in international dam projects.
You received this message as a subscriber on the list: email@example.com
To be removed from the list, please visit: